Wednesday, May 6, 2009

The Ugly Truth


I came across this picture a while ago and realized there was a lot of truth to it. However, as a stereotype, it has a sizable "hole" where an individual of group doesn't fulfill what the stereotype predicted. This room for error ranges from stereotype to stereotype.

For example, the statement "All Americans enjoy football" has slightly more truth than a statement like "All Americans get take-out and fast food every night." Additionally, these stereotypes can be "disproved" when an individual is raised in a way that deviates from the norms of society. For example, the percentage of immigrants that enjoy football is less than the percentage of American-born citizens.

I came to understand this gap in the picture recently. A couple friends and I made a chart of various aspects of intelligence to determine who was smarter of two girls (I'm pretty sure it was way too analytical and meticulous to be mere gossip). The categories we made related to a broader intelligence, rather than the highest SAT score type intelligence. These included knowledge, analysis, awareness, intuition, social skills, neuroticism (your ability to create new rocks), agreeableness and self-management

We'd give a score of one to ten, then total it up. Then we weighted these categories so that a difference in one of them would be more pronounced. For example, multiplying the score of self-management by two for each person would give the more organized and time-efficient person a greater advantage.

At the end of this, the girls watching decided to try it out for themselves. After staring at some of the categories for a little, they decided to make their own: clothes, hair, eyes, teeth, face, personality, comfortableness around the opposite sex, cockiness and a few more. Turns out that later, they didn't finish the list. They just made matches instead.

Although, our scale was intended to measure intelligence, not attractiveness, the precision and depth of our judgment sharply contrasted with the girls'. Although, we don't exactly go around looking for girls that are very adept at creating new rocks, we aren't solely fixated on physical beauty either.

The picture gives the message that the ugly truth is that men tend to be attracted more to physical beauty while women tend to be attracted to "inner" beauty. Just from overhearing locker room conversations from track, I know that only a small amount of guys feel strongly enough about inner beauty to speak about it publicly.

All throughout history, women had been viewed as inferior to men. Eventually, marriages developed from obligatory betrothals and diplomacy to meaningful relationships. However, there are still imbalances in the way gender roles play out in relationships. Coming from a highly materialistic society that holds models and actors in egregiously high esteem, this is not a surprise. Hopefully, our attitudes and mindsets can develop to marginalize or belittle physical beauty, and thereby making the message of "the ugly truth" less veritable.

No comments:

Post a Comment